Masters Insurance - Your local Nationwide Insurance Agency in Westerville, Ohio
Facebook Twitter Instagram Online Service Center
Main Office
178 W. Schrock Rd.
Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 471-7676 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
Reynoldsburg Branch

7620 Farmsbury Dr.
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
(614) 868-5850 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
S. Otterbein Branch
519 S. Otterbein Ave.
Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 471-7676 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
Get a Free Insurance Quote
Access Your Accounts Online
Sign Up for Online Access
Make Changes to Your Policy
Report a Claim | Pay My Bill

Masters Insurance is right here for you.

Our local insurance agents and financial advisors are dedicated to you, your family, and your future. We tailor a custom insurance plan that gives you the security to build a carefree life.

Talk to us about a personalized insurance package that eliminates insecure gaps in your coverage and identifies overlaps that could be costing you extra money.

When you need us, you know we are always right here.
In Central Ohio. In your neighborhood. In your corner.

Masters Insurance Group is dedicated to serving you with personal attention and insurance coverage that protects your family, your assets, and your future.


Great Customer Service
I just switched within the past year over to Masters Insurance and couldn't be happier that I made the change. At Masters Insurance, I feel that I am the top priority and the agents do everything they can to best suit my needs.

Read what our customers say about Masters Insurance Group

Schedule a free insurance review

Schedule an Right For You Review today to make sure your policy is working for you.

What's most important to you when selecting an insurance agency?

Solid reputation? Integrity and reliability? Trained professionals that know insurance and provide quality service? Affordable insurance plans that cover gaps and overlaps in your existing insurance protection?

At Masters Insurance Group, you'll receive all of these things from our team of experienced, licensed professionals who are committed to serving you. We've been a top-performing agency for more than 25 years, and we're one of the largest multi-line insurance agencies in Columbus, Ohio.

Our reputation has been built on years of extraordinary service, knowledge and trust.

Masters Insurance Group (MIG) has been serving the central Ohio community since 1996 with affordable insurance and financial services products. Our dedicated staff brings you over 100 years of combined experience and a daily commitment to providing professional service to all of our clients.

Service. The staff professionals at Masters Insurance Group are dedicated to serving you, our client. We listen to your needs, we fully describe the services we can offer and we work with you to construct a coverage package that will protect you, your family or your business for today and in the future.

Auto, Boat, Motorcycle and RV InsuranceAuto, Boat, Motorcycle & RV Insurance

We insure all types of vehicles, protecting your investment, should any damage, injury, or legal action occur. Insurance of this type is often required by lenders to protect their investment (auto loan), and is recommended protection for your own investment. We work with you to select the carrier and plan that fits your needs.

Learn about our Auto Insurance

Home, Farm, and Flood InsuranceHome, Farm & Flood Insurance

Property insurance protects you from a variety of losses to your property (such as your home and its contents), and coverage depends on the plan(s) that you select. Insurance of this type is often required by lenders to protect their investment (mortgage loan).

Life InsuranceLife Insurance

A life insurance policy provides peace of mind to you and your family in knowing that they will be provided for in the event of the insured person's death. The insurance company provides a lump-sum payment to the selected beneficiaries in the event of the insured's death. Term life insurance provides protection for a set period of time. Whole and universal life insurance provides lifetime coverage.

Business InsuranceBusiness Insurance

Business insurance protects your investment by minimizing financial risks associated with events such as a death of a partner, an injured employee, a lawsuit, fire, or another natural disaster. If your business is an LLC or a corporation, your personal assets are protected from business liabilities; however, neither business structure is a substitute for liability insurance, which covers your business from losses. Your lender or investors typically require you to maintain life, business interruption, fire, flood or other types of insurance to protect their investments.

Health InsuranceMore Insurance & Financial Services

  • Bonds
  • Disability Insurance
  • Health Insurance
  • Identity Theft Protection
  • Long Term Care Insurance
  • Personal Umbrella

View more financial services.

Research our financial advisors with BrokerCheck by FINRA. BrokerCheck helps you make informed choices about brokers and brokerage firms and provides easy access to investment adviser information.


Contact us File a claim Pay my bill