Masters Insurance - Your local Nationwide Insurance Agency in Westerville, Ohio
Facebook Twitter Instagram Online Service Center
Main Office
178 W. Schrock Rd.
Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 471-7676 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
Pickerington Branch
1258 Hill Rd. N.
Pickerington, OH 43147
(614) 868-5850 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
S. Otterbein Branch
519 S. Otterbein Ave.
Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 471-7676 Ph
(614) 467-2031 Fax
Get a Free Insurance Quote
Access Your Accounts Online
Sign Up for Online Access
Make Changes to Your Policy
Report a Claim | Pay My Bill

Contact Masters Insurance
(we want to listen to you)

We are available Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. After hours, please leave a message, email us, or use our Online Contact Form, and we will contact you as soon as possible.

Main Office
178 W. Schrock Road
Westerville, Ohio 43081-2873 (Map)

Phone: 614-471-7676
24-hr. Claims Line: 800-421-3535
Fax: 614-467-2031
Email: Send an email

 

Office Hours
Mon - Fri: 9 a.m. - 5 p.m., Evening By Appt.
Sat: By Appt.
Sun: Closed

Join Our Team!
Print an Employment Application

     

Pickerington Branch
1258 Hill Rd. N.
Pickerington, Ohio 43147 (Map)

Phone: 614-868-5850
24-hr. Claims Line: 800-421-3535
Fax: 614-467-2031
Email: Send an email

 

Office Hours
Mon - Fri: 9 a.m. - 5 p.m., Evening By Appt.
Sat: By Appt.
Sun: Closed

     

South Otterbein Branch
519 S. Otterbein Ave.
Westerville, OH 43081 (Map)

Phone: 614-471-7676
24-hr. Claims Line: 800-421-3535
Fax: 614-467-2031
Email: Send an email

 

Office Hours
Mon - Fri: 9 a.m. - 5 p.m., Evening By Appt.
Sat: By Appt.
Sun: Closed

     

How was our service?
Let us know

About Us

Masters Insurance Group (MIG) has been serving the central Ohio community since 1996 with affordable insurance and financial services products. The staff professionals at Masters Insurance Group are dedicated to serving you, our client. We listen to your needs, we fully describe the services we can offer and we work with you to construct a coverage package that will protect you, your family or your business for today and in the future.

Our Team

Greg Masters

 

Greg Masters
Principal Agent
614-471-7676
Email Greg

Bio: Greg has more than 27 years of service to the Central Ohio community.
Agency Awards: President's Award, Champion Award, NADP Agency of the Year.
Service Awards: Commercial Insurance Leadership Award, Life Insurance Leadership Award.

Darci McQueeney  

Darci McQueeney
Senior Account Manager
614-471-7676
Email Darci

Need a quote or to report a claim? Contact Darci for fast service.

Earl Borders

 

Earl Borders
VP Financial Services
614-471-7676
Email Earl

Erin Car

 

Erin Car
Client Care Associate
614-471-7676
Email Erin

  Kathy Carpenter
Account Manager
614-682-4730
Email Katherine
Ken Clutsam   Ken Clutsam
Account Manager
614-471-7676
Email Ken

Malinda Clutsam

 

Malinda Clutsam
Administrative Assistant
614-471-7676
Email Mailinda

Patricia Conrad

 

Patricia Conrad
Account Manager
614-471-7676
Email Patricia

 

Carol Conway
Employee Benefits Specialist
614-471-7676
Email Carol

Jerry Crabtree

 

Jerry Crabtree
Senior Associate Agent
614-471-7676
Email Jerry

Denise Crist

 

Denise Crist
Senior Account Manager
614-868-5850
Email Denise

Brenda Davidorf

 

Brenda Davidorf
Financial Associate
614-471-7676
Email Brenda

 

Stephanie Domer
Associate Agent
614-471-7676
Email Stephanie

Jim Levering

 

Jim Levering
Financial Associate
614-868-5850
Email Jim

Kevin Maclean

 

Kevin Maclean
Financial Associate
614-471-7676
Email Kevin

Dan Mussetter

 

Dan Mussetter
Client Care Associate
614-471-7676
Email Dan

Darlene Slater

 

Darlene Slater
Account Manager
614-471-7676
Email Darlene

Todd N. Tarney

 

Todd N. Tarney, SR, CMFC
Financial Associate
614-471-7676
Email Todd

Jillian VanMeter

 

Jillian VanMeter
Marketing Coordinator
614-868-5850
Email Jill

 

Matthew Yanchik
Account Manager
614-471-7676
Email Matthew

Review our coverage here and request a quote online or call us at 614-471-7676 for complete information and a free consultation.

We cannot bind new insurance coverage by electronic means.

Research our financial advisors with BrokerCheck by FINRA. BrokerCheck helps you make informed choices about brokers and brokerage firms and provides easy access to investment adviser information.

Contact us File a claim Pay my bill